Question: simplifying a/sqrt(tan(x+c__1)^2+1);

How to make Maple simplify a/sqrt(tan(x+c__1)^2+1); to a/sqrt(sec(x+c__1)^2);  ?

Below is worksheet. since the second one is smaller in leaf size, expected simplify(...,size) to do it, But it did not. Any suggestions?

24832

LC:=MmaTranslator:-Mma:-LeafCount;
e1:=a/sqrt(tan(x+c__1)^2+1);
e2:=a/sqrt(sec(x+c__1)^2);

MmaTranslator:-Mma:-LeafCount

a/(tan(x+c__1)^2+1)^(1/2)

a/(sec(x+c__1)^2)^(1/2)

LC(e1);

12

LC(e2);

10

#we see they are same
simplify(e1-e2);

0

#both nothing below make e1 to e2
simplify(e1); #not good simplification at all. Adds csgn.
LC(%);

a*csgn(sec(x+c__1))*cos(x+c__1)

11

#expected this to do it but no
simplify(e1,size);
LC(%);

a/(tan(x+c__1)^2+1)^(1/2)

12

simplify(e1,trig);

a/(tan(x+c__1)^2+1)^(1/2)

combine(e1,trig);

a/(tan(x+c__1)^2+1)^(1/2)

 


Using some other software:

 

 

 

Download tan_sec_simplification_june_9_2024.mw

Please Wait...