Preben Alsholm

13728 Reputation

22 Badges

20 years, 247 days

MaplePrimes Activity


These are questions asked by Preben Alsholm

To me the following behavior of solve is surprising:

restart;
solve(f(0.5)=7,f(0.5)); #Output NULL
solve(f(1/2)=7,f(1/2)); #Output as expected 7

Debugging solve suggested to me that the following might work
solve(f(0.5)=7,f(1/2));
and indeed it did (outout the float 7.).
This behavior seems to have started in Maple 10. I checked Maple V,R3 and several other old versions including Maple 9.5. All behaved as I would have expected. MapleV,R3 gave the float 7. in the first case, the other the integer 7.
I take this to be a bug and shall file an SCR.
Any comments?




I'm not being notified anymore about responses to answers or comments to MaplePrimes. I'm assuming that I'm not the only one (?). This has happened before.

A large procedure I made caused me some problems. I finally found the source of the problem.
There seems to be some interaction between the end of parameters marker, $, and the elementwise operation ~.

Consider these 3 versions of essentially the same procedure:

restart;
Q1:=proc(Var::list,$) local n;
  n:=nops(Var);
  print(Var,n);
  proc(var::list)
       subs(Var=~[seq(1..n)],var); #Elementwise
  end proc;
end proc:
Q1([x,y]); #Doesn't work : "invalid expression"
Q2:=proc(Var::list,$) local n;
  n:=nops(Var);
  print(Var,n);
  proc(var::list)
      subs(zip(`=`,Var,[seq(1..n)]),var); # zip
  end proc;
end proc:
Q2([x,y]); #No problem
Q3:=proc(Var::list) local n; #No end of parameters marker $
  n:=nops(Var);
  print(Var,n);
  proc(var::list)
       subs(Var=~[seq(1..n)],var); # Elementwise
  end proc;
end proc:
Q3([x,y]); # No problem
lprint(Q3([x,y])); #Curious output involving ` $`
#A fourth procedure in which the output is not a procedure works:
Q4:=proc(Var::list,$) local n;
  n:=nops(Var);
  print(Var,n);
  subs(Var=~[seq(1..n)],Var)
end proc:
Q4([x,y]);

Does anybody have any comments? Is it a bug?

Any plans of correcting the obvious problem the MaplePrimes text editor has with the inequality sign < ?
It is really quite annoying.
Everything on a line of code after < is very often discarded with the obvious effect that the code doesn't run.

For a while I haven't received notifications about updates to answers and comments from MaplePrimes. Is that due to the recent problem with fake messages from Maple?

1 2 3 4 5 Page 4 of 5