Maple Questions and Posts

These are Posts and Questions associated with the product, Maple

I believe this is a bug:

subsindets(%, anything^rational, proc(x) if type(x, specfunc(anything, Q)^rational) then 'Q(x)' else 'x' fi end)<>
subsindets(%, specfunc(anything, Q)^rational, Q);


WE20 Oceanography Historical Perspective


Maple is a trademark of Waterloo Maple Inc.


Adapted from Introductory Oceanography 10th ed. by Harold V. Thurman and Alan P. Trujillo


1.  How did the view of the ocean by early Mediterranean cultures influence the naming of planet Earth?


Early cultures envisioned the world as composed of large landmasses surrounded by marginal bodies of water.


2.  What is the difference between an ocean and a sea?  Which ones are the seven seas?


A sea is

   •  Smaller and shallower than an ocean (this is why the Arctic Ocean might be more appropriately considered a sea)

   •  Composed of salt water (many "seas" such as the Caspian Sea in Asia, are actually large fresh water lakes)

   •  Somewhat enclosed by land (but some seas, such as the Sargasso Sea in the Atlantic Ocean, are defined by strong ocean currents rather than land.


The seven seas:  the North Pacifiic, the South Pacific, the North Atlantic, the South Atlantic, the Indian, the Arctic, and the Southern or Antarctic.


3.  Describe the development of navigation techniques that have enabled sailors to navigate the open ocean far from land.


Initially, navigators in the Northern Hemisphere measured the angle between the horizon and the North Star (Polaris), which is directly above the North Pole.  Latitude could be determined by noting the angular difference between the horizon and the North Star.  In the Southern Hemisphere, the angle between the horizon and the Southern Cross was used because the Southern Cross is directly overhead at the South Pole.


There was no method of determining longitude until one based on time was developed at the end of the 18th century.  Pendulum-driven clocks in use in the early 1700s would not work for long on a rocking ship at sea.  In 1728 a cabinetmaker in Lincolnshire, England, named John Harrison, began working on a new type of time peace.  The "chronometer" was driven by a helical balance spring that remained horizontal and independent of ship motion.


As Earth turns on its rotational axis it moves through 2Pi radian every 24 hours (one complete rotation).  Earth, therefore, rotates through (1/12)*Pi radian of longitude per hour.  As a result, a navigator need only know the time at the prime or Greenwich at the exact same time the sun is at its highest point (local noon) at the ship's location.


Suppose a ship sets sail west across the Atlantic Ocean from Europe, checking its longitude each day when the sun is at its highest point (solar noon) at the ship's location.  On one day the chronometer reads 16:18 hours.  What is the location of the ship?


The ship is 4 hours and 18 minutes behind (west of) Greenwich time.  To determine the longitude we must convert time into longitude.  


(1/12)*Pi radian of longitude per hour

(1/12)*Pi*(1/60) = (1/720)*Piradian of longitude per minute

(1/720)*Pi*(1/60) = (1/43200)*Piradian of longitude per second


4*((1/12)*Pi)+18*((1/720)*Pi) = 43*Pi*(1/120)


180*(43*Pi*(1/120))/Pi = 7740*(1/120) and 7740*(1/120) = 129/2 and 129/2 = 64.5degree west of the Greenwich meridian.


In Maple:

dg := proc (hr, mn, sc) local r, d, d_dec; r := (1/12)*hr*Pi+(1/720)*mn*Pi+(1/4320)*sc*Pi; d := 180*r/Pi; d_dec := evalf[5](d); print(d, d_dec) end proc

dg(4, 18, 0)

129/2, 64.500


4.  Construct a time line that includes the major events of human history that have resulted in greater understanding of our planet in general and the oceans in particular.







5.  Using a diagram, illustrate the method used by Eratosthenes to calculate the circumference of Earth.


Eratoshenes (276–192 BCE) had heard that at noon on the longest day of the year the Sun shone directly into the waters of a deep,vertical well in Syene (Aswan), which was 800 kilometers (500 miles) to the south.  At the same time in Alexandria, he noticed a vertical pole cast a slight shadow when the Sun was at its apex in the sky over Alexandria.  He accurately measured the shadow the pole cast, which was 7.2 degree.


Convert 7.2 ° to radian  alpha^R = ((1/180)*Pi*`#msup(mi("&alpha;",fontstyle = "normal"),mo("&compfn;"))`*Pi)*`#msup(mn("7.2"),mo("&compfn;"))` and ((1/180)*Pi*`#msup(mi("&alpha;",fontstyle = "normal"),mo("&compfn;"))`*Pi)*`#msup(mn("7.2"),mo("&compfn;"))` = (1/25)*Pi




convert(0.4000000000e-1, 'rational', 'exact')



(2*Pi*800)*km/((1/25)*Pi) = 40000*km




 The equatorial circumference of Earth is about 24,901 miles (40,075 km). However, from pole-to-pole — the meridional circumference — Earth is only 24,860 miles (40,008 km) around. This shape, caused by the flattening at the poles, is called an oblate spheroid.  Since Eratoshenes was calculating the meridional circumference, his calculation was only 8 km different from the accepted modern measurement.


The following calculations are for the diagram.


NULLNULL`implies`(40000/(2*Pi) = 20000*alpha/Pi and 20000*alpha/Pi = (1/25)*Pi*sin(alpha) and (1/25)*Pi*sin(alpha) = y/c, c*sin(alpha) = y)

`&approx;`(20000*sin((1/25)*Pi)/Pi, 798*kg)NULLNULL







`implies`(tan(alpha) = y/x implies tan(alpha)/y = 1/x, y/tan(alpha) = 20000*x*sin((1/25)*Pi)/(Pi*tan((1/25)*Pi)) and `&approx;`(20000*x*sin((1/25)*Pi)/(Pi*tan((1/25)*Pi)), 6316*km))









with(plottools); with(plots)

p1 := circle([0, 0], 20000/Pi)

p2 := line([0, 0], [6316, 798])

p3 := line([0, 0], [6316, 0])

p4 := pointplot([[6316, 0], [6316, 798]], color = yellow, symbol = solidcircle, symbolsize = 25, transparency = .3)

p5 := textplot({[4400, -600, "Syene (Aswan)"], [4400, 1300, "Alexandria"]}, font = [Perpetua, bold, 18])

display(p1, p2, p3, p4, p5, scaling = constrained, size = [350, 350], axes = none)



6.  While the Arabs dominated the Mediterranean region during the Middle Ages, what were the most significant ocean-related events taking place in Europe?


Between 831 and 1071, the Emirate of Sicily was one of the major centers of Islamic culture in the Mediterranean. After its conquest by the Christian Normans, the island developed its own distinct culture with the fusion of Latin and Byzantine influences. Palermo remained a leading artistic and commercial center of the Mediterranean well into the Middle Ages.


Europe was reviving, however, as more organized and centralized states began to form in the later Middle Ages after the Renaissance of the 12th century. Motivated by religion and dreams of conquest, the kings of Europe launched a number of Crusades to try to roll back Muslim power and retake the holy land. The Crusades were unsuccessful in this goal, but they were far more effective in weakening the already tottering Byzantine Empire that began to lose increasing amounts of territory to the Seljuk Turks and later to the Ottoman Turks. They also rearranged the balance of power in the Muslim world as Egypt once again emerged as a major power in the eastern Mediterranean.


7.  Describe the important events in oceanography that occurred during the Age of Discovery in Europe.


One of the most famous voyages during the Age of Discovery began in 1768 when the HMS Endeavour left Portsmouth, England, under the command of Captain James Cook. Over 10 years Cook led three world-encircling expeditions and mapped many countries, including Australia, New Zealand and the Hawaiian Islands. He was an expert seaman, navigator and scientist who made keen observations wherever he went. He was also one of the first ship captains to recognize that a lack of Vitamin C in sailors’ diets (due mostly to a lack of fresh fruit) caused scurvy, a serious disease that killed many sailors in those times. Cook always sailed with lots of pickled cabbage, which he insisted that the sailors eat. Scurvy was never a problem on his ships because the cabbage contained lots of Vitamin C.


8.  List some of the major achievements of Captain James Cook.


Three important voyages commanded by Captain Cook:  

1771–1768  Endeavor observes the transit of Venus in Tahiti; charts New Zealand; charts the eastern coastline of Australia and continues on to New Guinea and Java.


1772–1776 Resolution crosses the Anartic circle for the first time in history.  On returning to England Cook writes about preventing scurvy on long voyages.


1776–1779 Resolution and Discovery visit New Zealand, Tonga, Tahiti, and Christmas Island; Hawaiian islands discovered; expedition crosses the Pacific eastwards to make landfall off the coast of Oregon.  Cook sails into the Bering Straits but foiled by ice he returns to Hawaii where he is killed by natives on 14 Feb 1779.


9.  Describe, in general, the voyages of  HMS Challenger and HMS Beagle.


The Beagle sailed from Plymouth Sound on 27 December 1831 under the command of Captain Robert FitzRoy. While the expedition was originally planned to last two years, it lasted almost five—the Beagle did not return until 2 October 1836. Darwin spent most of this time exploring on land (three years and three months on land; 18 months at sea). The book he wrote is a vivid travel memoir as well as a detailed scientific field journal covering biology, geology, and anthropology that demonstrates Darwin's keen powers of observation, written at a time when Western Europeans were exploring and charting the whole world.


Darwin's notes made during the voyage include comments hinting at his changing views on the inflexibility of species. On his return to England, he wrote the book based on these notes, at a time when he was first developing his theories of evolution through common descent and natural selection. The book includes some suggestions of his ideas, particularly in the second edition of 1845 (Thurman and Trujillo, p. 23).


On December 21, 1872 the HMS. Challenger sailed from Portsmouth, England, for an epic voyage which would last almost three and a half years. It  was the first expedition organized and funded for a specific scientific purpose: to examine the deep-sea floor and answer questions about the ocean environment.  Although the mission was scientific, another purpose was to collect information that could be used in the laying of communication cables along the sea floor.


The expedition covered 69,000 miles (about 130,000 km) and gathered data on currents, water chemistry, temperature, bottom deposits and marine life at 362 oceanographic stations. More than 4700 new species of marine animals were discovered during the course of the voyage, many of which were found on the seafloor – an environment that scientists originally believed to be too inhospitable to support life (


10.  Describe the voyages of the Fram and how it helped prove there was no continent beneath the Arctic ice pack.


The Fram was the first ship specially built (in Norway) for polar research. She was used on three important expeditions: with Fridtjof Nansen on a drift over the Arctic Ocean 1893-96, with Otto Sverdrup to the arctic archipelago west of Greenland - now the Nunavut region of Canada - 1898-1902, and with Roald Amundsen to Antarctica for his South Pole expedition 1910-12. The Fram is now housed and exhibited in the Fram Museum at Bygdøynes, Oslo



11.  Why did Benjamin Franklin want to know about the surface current pattern in the North Atlantic Ocean?


As Deputy Postmaster General of the American colonies, Franklin promoted using the Gulf Stream to speed up delivery of mail from America to Europe, as well as to improve other commercial shipping (


12.  What was Alexander Agassiz's major contribution to an increased knowledge of the oceans?


Agassiz is widely acknowledged as the driving force that brought oceanography recognition as a science.  His training as a mining engineer led him to develop ingenious oceanographic sampling devices—the prototypes for many devices in use on research vessels today—that improved the quantitative value of biological sampling (Thurman and Trujillo, p. 27).


13.  What important oceanographic inventions and data came out of Word Wars I and II?

The need to detect submarines led the navies of the world to greatly expand their studies of the sea. This led to the founding of oceanography departments at state universities, including Oregon State, Texas A&M University, University of Miami, and University of Rhode Island,

and the founding of national ocean laboratories such as the various Institutes of Oceanographic Science ( stewart_ocean_book.pdf).


14.  List features of the oceans that can be studied remotely by use of satellites.


• phytoplankton concentrations

• heat storage and aerosol formation and other ocean influences on climate processes

• cycles of carbon, sulfur, and nitrogen concentrations


• Bathymetry/Seafloor (Bathymetry is the measurement of depth of water in oceans seas, or lakes)

• Topography

• Costal Process

• Marine Geophysics

• Ocean Acoustics

• Ocean Chemistry

• Ocean Circulation

• Ocean Heat Budget

• Ocean Optics

• Ocean Pressure

• Ocean Temperature

• Ocean Waves

• Ocean Winds

• Salinity/Density

• Sea ice

• Sea Surface Topography



15.  Discuss what problems the human body can experience as a result of diving underwater.


Nitrogen narcosis (also referred to as inert gas narcosis, raptures of the deep, and the Martini effect) :  While scuba diving does sometimes involve breathing air that’s mixed with nitrogen, this condition is caused when the diver goes deeper into the water, where the partial pressure of nitrogen increases and more nitrogen ends up getting absorbed into the bloodstream. The higher the nitrogen concentration in the bloodstream, the slower the nervous system will be, and the more likely the diver will experience intoxicating effects that can seriously impair their judgment underwater—possibly enough to lead them into dangerous situations (


Barotrauma: Trauma caused by rapid or extreme changes in air pressure, especially affecting enclosed cavities within the body such as the middle ear (otic barotrauma), the sinuses (sinus barotrauma), and the lungs (pulmonary barotrauma) (


Decompression illness is caused by intravascular or extravascular bubbles that are formed as a result of reduction in environmental pressure (decompression). The term covers both arterial gas embolism, in which alveolar gas or venous gas emboli (via cardiac shunts or via pulmonary vessels) are introduced into the arterial circulation, and decompression sickness, which is caused by in-situ bubble formation from dissolved inert gas. Both syndromes can occur in divers, compressed air workers, aviators, and astronauts, but arterial gas embolism also arises from iatrogenic causes unrelated to decompression. Risk of decompression illness is affected by immersion, exercise, and heat or cold. Manifestations range from itching and minor pain to neurological symptoms, cardiac collapse, and death. First-aid treatment is 100% oxygen and definitive treatment is recompression to increased pressure, breathing 100% oxygen. Adjunctive treatment, including fluid administration and prophylaxis against venous thromboembolism in paralysed patients, is also recommended. Treatment is, in most cases, effective although residual deficits can remain in serious cases, even after several recompressions (



Suppose we have a number of points, n, in the x-y plane and the location of each point is known.

I wish to evaluate the straight-line distance from point to point and tabulate these values (i.e. A to B, A to C, A to D, B to C, B to D, etc) and then plot the points in question.

In this attached worksheet, I have given an example of 4 points and I would welcome all suggestions on how to do this. 

Thanks for reading.


We are currently in the process of updating the support FAQs at We’ve been working on updating the existing content for clarity, and have added several new articles already.


The majority of our FAQs are from questions people ask us in Technical Support at, but we’d also like to like to add content from other sources.

Since we have such a great community here at MaplePrimes, we wanted to reach out and ask if there are any articles or questions that you'd like to see added to our FAQ.


We look forward to hearing your feedback!

I'm new to Maple.

My problem is that if I input the command sqrt(3.0), for example, I get this strange result:

1.81847767202745*10^(-58) + (7.53238114626421*10^(-59))*I

The results is the same, no matter the argument of sqrt.

Also, when using ln, I get this:

-265.745524189222 + 0.785398163397448*I

Again, no matter the argument of ln, the result is the same.

What is happening?

Dear maple user  any one suggest me how to solve  second order coupled differential equation using galerkin finite element method for 8 elements and 10 elements using maple codes


I thought I remembed how to do this once in Maple, or asking something like this here, but may be it was something similar. But I am not able to figure it now or remember.

Given an expression, I want to find all occuranes of a pattern in it.  Not just one.  So this is like using patmatch but over and over again untill all patterns found. I'll give an example to make it easy to explain.


expr := y^2*sin(1/y) + y^(3/2) + y + x*y^7;

I want to find all patterns of form y^n  so the result should be 

{y^(3/2), y^7, y^2, 1/y, y}

This below is how it is done in Mathematica, but having hard time translating this code to Maple.

The last line below does the actual repeated pattern matching. That line was not written by me. It is something from Mathematica forum at stackexchange and I use it all the time and it works well.

expr = y^2*Sin[1/y] + y^(3/2) + y + x*y^7;
pat = y^n_.;
Last@Reap[expr /. a : pat :> Sow[a], _, Sequence @@ #2 &]

I looked at hastype also. But hastype will only tell me if the pattern is there or not. May be I did not use it right.

expr := y^2*sin(1/y) + y^(3/2) + y + x*y^7;

Gives true

I tried patmatch, but again, it only find one:

expr := y^2*sin(1/y) + y^(3/2) + y + x*y^7;
if patmatch(expr,a::anything+y^(n::anything)+b::anything,'la') then

And the above is not even robust for finding one. Since I have to change the pattern again to account for multiplication/addition cases between terms. 

Is it possible to do in Maple the same thing I show in Mathematica? I am sure it is possible, but can't now find the right function in Maple.

Maple 2019.1

Should I adjust numcpus while running thread command

I want to extract lists that are term by term smaller than a fix one.

To be clearer, I want to create something like

if a[i] <= b[i] for all i=1..min(nops(a),nops(b)) then ...

I tried with the forall call, but it doesn't work:

if forall( i=1..min(nops(a),nops(b)),a[i] <= b[i]) then ...

I also tried the assuming call with the is call. It works, but doesnt't give me the result I want:


if is(a[i] <= b[i]) assuming(1 <= i, i <= min(nops(a),nops(b))) then...

Is there a way to have a chain of conditions in a if statement like I am trying to do?

I experienced a significant obstacle while trying to generate independent random samples with Statistics:-Sample on different nodes of a Grid multi-processing environment. After many hours of trial-and-error, I discovered an astonishing workaround, and I achieved excellent time and memory performance. Since this seems like a generally useful computation, I thought that it was worthy of a Post.

This Post is also worth reading to learn how to use Grid when you need to initialize a substantial environment on each node before using Grid:-Map or Grid:-Seq.

All remaining details are in the following worksheet.

How to use Statistics:-Sample in the `Grid` environment

Author: Carl Love <> 1 August 2019


I experienced a significant obstacle while trying to generate indenpendent random samples with Statistics:-Sample on the nodes of a multi-processor Grid (on a single computer). After several hours of trial-and-error, I discovered that two things are necessary to do this:


The random number generator needs to be seeded differently in each node. (The reason for this is easy to understand.)


The random variables generated by Statistics:-RandomVariable need to have different names in each node. This one is mind-boggling to me. Afterall, each node has its own kernel and so its own memory It's as if the names of random variables are stored in a disk file which all kernels access. And also the generator has been seeded differently in each node.


Once these things were done, the time and memory performance of the computation were excellent.


Digits:= 15

#Specify the size of the computation:
(n1,n2,n3):= (100, 100, 1000):
# n1 = size of each random sample;
# n2 = number of samples in a batch;
# n3 = number of batches.

#Procedure to initialize needed globals on each node:
Init:= proc(n::posint)
local node:= Grid:-MyNode();
   #This is wrapped in parse so that it'll act globally. Otherwise, an environment
   #variable would be reset when this procedure ends.
   parse("Digits:= 15;", 'statement');

   randomize(randomize()+node); #Initialize independent RNG for this node.
   #If repeatability of results is desired, remove the inner randomize().

   (:-X,:-Y):= Array(1..n, 'datatype'= 'hfloat') $ 2;

   #Perhaps due to some oversight in the design of Statistics, it seems necessary that
   #r.v.s in different nodes **need different names** in order to be independent:
   N||node:= Statistics:-RandomVariable('Normal'(0,1));
   :-TRS:= (X::rtable)-> Statistics:-Sample(N||node, X);
   #To verify that different names are needed, change N||node to N in both lines.
   #Doing so, each node will generate identical samples!

   #Perform some computation. For the pedagogical purpose of this worksheet, all that
   #matters is that it's some numeric computation on some Arrays of random Samples.
   :-GG:= (X::Array, Y::Array)->
         proc(X::Array, Y::Array, n::posint)
         local s, k, S:= 0, p:= 2*Pi;
            for k to n do
               s:= sin(p*X[k]);  
               S:= S + X[k]^2*cos(p*Y[k])/sqrt(2-sin(s)) + Y[k]^2*s
         end proc
         (X, Y, n)
   #Perform a batch of the above computations, and somehow numerically consolidate the
   #results. Once again, pedagogically it doesn't matter how they're consolidated.  
   :-TRX1:= (n::posint)-> add(GG(TRS(X), TRS(Y)), 1..n);
   #It doesn't matter much what's returned. Returning `node` lets us verify that we're
   #actually running this on a grid.
   return node
end proc

The procedure Init above uses the :- syntax to set variables globally for each node. The variables set are X, Y, N||node, TRS, GG, and TRX1. Names constructed by concatenation, such as N||node, are always global, so :- isn't needed for those.

#Time the initialization:
st:= time[real]():
   #Send Init to each node, but don't run it yet:
   #Run Init on each node:
   Nodes:= Grid:-Run(Init, [n1], 'wait');
time__init_Grid:= time[real]() - st;

Array(%id = 18446745861500764518)


The only purpose of array Nodes is that it lets us count the nodes, and it lets us verify that Grid:-MyNode() returned a different value on each node.

num_nodes:= numelems(Nodes);


#Time the actual execution:
st:= time[real]():
   R1:= [Grid:-Seq['tasksize'= iquo(n3, num_nodes)](TRX1(k), k= [n2 $ n3])]:
time__run_Grid:= time[real]() - st


#Just for comparison, run it sequentially:
st:= time[real]():
time__init_noGrid:= time[real]() - st;

st:= time[real]():
   R2:= [seq(TRX1(k), k= [n2 $ n3])]:
time__run_noGrid:= time[real]() - st;



R1 and R2 will be different because different random numbers were used, but they should have similar histograms.

      <R1 | R2>, #side-by-side plots
      'title'=~ <<"With Grid\n"> | <"Without Grid\n">>,
      'gridlines'= false

(Plot output deleted because MaplePrimes cannot handle side-by-side plots!)

They look similar enough to me!


Let's try to quantify the benefit of using Grid:

speedup_factor:= time__run_noGrid / time__run_Grid;


Express that as a fraction of the theoretical maximum speedup:

efficiency:= speedup_factor / num_nodes;


I think that that's really good!


The memory usage of this code is insignificant, which can be verified from an external memory monitor such as Winodws Task Manager. It's just a little bit more than that needed to start a kernel on each node. It's also possible to measure the memory usage programmatically. Doing so for a Grid:-Seq computation is a little bit beyond the scope of this worksheet.




Here are the histograms:



How to show the y-axis numbers in the second plot ?   y is in [0,3]. 

I try the following but it shows a negative axis. 

display(P, L, axis = [tickmarks = [5, subticks = 3], thickness = 2]);  this is not correct

The file is attached.





I do not understand why the following is not working. I have a package which has a module inside it. The module is exported by the package.

Inside that module, there is a proc, which is also exported by the module.

So why can't one call the proc from outside the package? What Am I doing wrong? and how to correct it? I'd like to be able to call the proc directly. 

  option package;
  export B;
  B := module()
      export foo;

           print("in foo");
      end proc;

  end module;
end module;   

Now when typing (A::B):-foo() Maple is not happy and says Error, module does not export `foo`

I tried different syntax from the above, but can't get it to work. For example A::B:-foo() gives Error, `B` does not evaluate to a module


Maple 2019.1

P; Q; lma; [3 -42] [-, ---] [2 25 ] [22649 -2304] [-----, -----] [5523 1841 ] 1.627112258 with(geometry); point(Pp, P[1], P[2]); point(Qp, Q[1], Q[2]); ellipse(p, ['foci' = [Pp, Qp], 'MajorAxis' = lma]); Error, (in geometry:-ellipse) the given polynomial/equation is not an algebraic representation of a ellipse; I can't understand this error

Hi I’m a student, running Maple on a student license, and I have an issue with the way the Maple 2019 setup is.

I'm sorry if my answer is a bit hard to understand, I don't really know how to explain it.

My Maple 2018 expired and I was forced to upgrade to Maple 2019, however for me there is a huge difference in how the setup is in therms of “math” and “text” mode. 


Before, I was able to easily switch between “text” and “math” mode in a paragraph (the red “>”) in my worksheet, by using “cmd+R” and “cmd+T”. So I would have paragraphs for text, where i could switch between “math” and “text” for writing, and then I would have paragraphs only for math for when I would calculate things. (I’ve tried to screenshot how it would typically look)


Mt problem with Maple 2019, is that when I switch a paragraph into text and start writing and want to switch to “math” by using “cmd+R”, Maple executes the formula whenever I press “enter”, and give me an output I don’t want.


How do I change the settings to get back to the way they were on Maple 2018 and the years before this?

Thanks in advance.

(I know I can put a ":" after the "math" part in my text, but i don't wan't to do it every time)




When making a proc that accepts positional and keyword based arguments, Maple allows the caller to put the keyword arguments before or after the positional arguments, or in between.

Is there a way to force the keyword arguments (if they are used) to only be placed after the (required) positional arguments during the call? 

An example will make it more clear. Given this proc

foo := proc(a::integer, b::integer, {c::integer:= 1, d::integer:= 1},$)
    print("a=",a," b=",b," c=",c," d=",d);
end proc:

It can be called as any one of these cases

foo(1,2);                                #case 1                                             
foo(1, 2,'c' = 1, 'd' = 2);              #case 2
foo('c' = 1, 1, 'd' = 2, 2);             #case 3
foo('c' = 1, 1, 2);                      #case 4
foo(1, 'c'=1, 2);                        #case 5
#more combinations possible

Is it possible to change how proc is defined, so that Maple will accept case1, and case 2 only in the above when the call is made and give an error otherwise?

i.e. only allow keyword arguments after all positional arguments.  I read  and it says

After all arguments matching keyword parameters have been processed, matching of required positional and optional or expected ordered parameters is carried out

So from above, it looks like what I am asking for is not really possible. But I thought to ask, in case there is some way.

I find ability to put keyword arguments in the call anywhere and in-between required positional arguments confusing that is all.

Maple 2019.1

5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Last Page 7 of 1574